A week ago, I put together a roundtable about the upcoming mobile platform wars between the iPhone, Google’s Android, and older platforms like Nokia’s. One thing I discovered as I was organizing the event was that it was really hard to find anyone developing Android apps other than the 50 people who won the Android Developer’s Challenge. (We tried to get someone from Android on the panel, but Google declined to participate).

Most of the 20 CEOs, developers and VCs on the roundtable were more interested in the iPhone, Nokia, and other platforms that actually exist as something other than a software emulation. Their attitude seemed to be: Show me the phones.

Pandora CTO Tony Conrad went even further, saying, “I need Android like I need a hole in the head.� To which Michael responded: “As soon as it launches, you are going to be kissing Google’s ass and you are going to be launching on their platform.� Here’s a clip with Tony and Michael going at it:

Another debate was whether the iPhone is really anything new. AdMob CEO Omar Hamoui (in T-shirt) argued that it indeed represents a fundamental shift because it is the first time most people are actually using the mobile Web, regardless of how long it’s been around. (This was basically the premise of the panel). Skydeck CEO Jason Devitt (in striped shirt) pointed out that the existing mobile Web is already a fairly large market, citing a figure of $700 million spent on mobile games alone. Devitt, though, is old-school (he previously founded Vindigo), and even he admits that he doesn’t browse the Web on most phones other than the Phone.

Source : http://www.techcrunch.com/2008/08/02/mobile-web-wars-videos-does-anybody-care-about-android/

Back in 1984, Apple was on top of the computing world with top-notch sexy hardware and it partnered with Microsoft for some top-notch [not so] sexy practical software. It was a winning combination for both Apple and Microsoft. Microsoft’s strategy in 1984 was hardware agnostic making its software available on any popular platform. Apple’s strategy in 1984 was holistic. We’ll call the period between 1984 and 2000, Round 1.

In Round 1, it turned out that Microsoft’s strategy was the clear-cut winner. By being hardware agnostic, hardware vendors competed with one-another to drive down the price of hardware much faster than anyone could have imagined. Clone prices fell so fast and so much lower than the price of a Macintosh that it simply became impractical to own a Mac. Software vendors also took note and quickly the non-Mac-PC became the standard. Apple nearly died.

2007 set off Round 2. This time around it’s in the cell phone business. Once again, Apple is on top of the Cell Phone game with top-notch sexy hardware and it has partnered with Google this time for some top-notch [not so] sexy practical software (think Google Maps, YouTube and other web-based Google Apps for the iPhone). Once again, it’s a winning partnership for both Apple and Google. And Once again, Google’s strategy is exactly the same to that of Microsoft in 1984: stay hardware agnostic. Apple’s strategy is also identical to its own strategy back in 1984: stay holistic. Round 2 has begun.

The similarities are eery. In 1984, while Microsoft was building the most popular application software on the Mac, it had begun a similar hardware-agnostic operating system (Windows) on its own. In 2007, while Google has some of the most popular application software on iPhone, it has begun a similar hardware agnostic Cell-Phone operating system (Android) on its own. Apple’s strategy has not changed a single bit. It refuses to license its operating system or any other technology while it continues to want more and more control over the entirety of the experience. The iPhone in 2007 has set off a brand new race much like the original Macintosh did in 1984. Interestingly, 24 years later, the strategies are still identical on both sides.

So will Round 2 end in the same way with Google’s Android prevailing due to exceptionally cheap phones that are sure to emerge using Android? Maybe not. There is one key difference between Round 1 & Round 2: Steve Jobs. Steve didn’t get to finish fighting the strategy that he helped establish for Apple in Round 1. He left Apple in 1985. So there’s no telling how things would have turned out. The fact that Apple lost round 1 may have taught everyone a lesson and it might falsely embolden Google to think Microsoft’s winning strategy was the better strategy. After all, Google’s chief, Eric Schmit, has been learning from (and losing to) Microsoft for 20+ years. Eric is now using Microsoft’s own strategy to successfully beat them. Google is the new Microsoft.

But this time around Steve is much smarter than he was in 1984. So smart in fact, that he’s resurrected Round 1 from the dead and may still pull off a win (the Mac is coming back). It’s possible that Steve & Apple’s holistic approach will still be the winning approach for Round 1, assuming you extend round 1 to at least 2015. But in Round 2 Apple’s chances are a lot better. Everybody is at the beginning of the race. There are no clear winners and just like in 1984, Apple has a major lead. It’ll be interesting to see what happens.

I’m curious to know your thoughts on:

• Who you think will win Round 2: will it be Google with its Android or Apple with its iPhone?
• Is Round 1 over in your view or will the Mac eventually beat out Windows-based PCs in market share?
• Is Microsoft even a player in Round 2? (I would never recommend a current Windows-Mobile phone to my worst enemy - so do they even stand a chance?)

On Monday, November 12, 2007, Google released Android, a complete Linux based software stack aimed directly at the cell phone marketplace. I’ll let others talk about what it means for other players in the marketplace, the intricacies of GPL2 vs the Apache License, etc. This article dives straight into the heart of the SDK and API itself, summarizing some of the documentation provided by Google, then jumping into building an application using Android.

Android Emulator

(Click to enlarge)

So, what Is Android?

Android is a complete software stack for mobile devices such as cell phones, PDAs and high end MP3 players. The software stack is split into four layers:

• The application layer
• The application framework
• The libraries and runtime
• The kernel

Cell phone users obviously work with applications in the application layer. Android developers write those applications using the application framework. Unlike many embedded operating environments, Android applications are all equal — that is, the applications that come with the phone are no different than those that any developer writes. In fact, using the IntentFilter API, any application can handle any event that the user or system can generate. This sounds a bit scary at first, but Android has a well thought-out security model based on Unix file system permissions that assure applications have only those abilities that cell phone owner gave them at install time. The framework is supported by numerous open source libraries such as openssl, sqlite and libc. It is also supported by the Android core libraries — more on that in a second. At the bottom of the stack sits the Linux 2.6 kernel, providing the low level hardware interfaces that we all expect from a kernel. This is a Unix based system — that is, the Unix C APIs are available — but don’t expect to drop to a shell and start executing shell scripts with your old friends grep and awk. Most of the Unix utilities are simply not there. Instead Android supplies a well thought out API for writing applications — in Java using the Android core libraries.

That’s right, Android applications are almost exclusively written in Java. The Android core library is a big .jar file that is supported by the Dalvik Virtual Machine — a fast and efficient JVM work-alike that enables java-coded applications to work on the Android cell phone. This is similar to, but not the same as using Sun’s JVM directly.

Building your development environment

Google provides three versions of the SDK; one for Windows, one for Mac OSX (intel) and one for Linux (x86). They also provide two development environments — one is Eclipse based, and the other is a “roll your own.” The Eclipse based environment is quite feature-rich and should suffice for most developers. There is no reason that you can’t use both Eclipse and “roll your own.”

If you get stuck in eclipse (like I did), you may find yourself dropping to the command-line interfaces to see what’s really going on. However for this article, I’ll assume that you’re using the Eclipse IDE for your Android software development needs. Once you’ve downloaded the Android SDK, Eclipse and the Eclipse Plugin, you should work through the first few sections of Google’s install document (System and Software Requirements, Installing the SDK, Installing the Eclipse Plugin). I’d leave the rest of the document for later as it does get quite detailed quickly.

Read the Friendly Manual

Google has done a good job of writing a lot of documentation for Android. However, there isn’t a great way of knowing what’s important to read now vs. what can wait. Here are some links to documents that are important to understand what Android is and how to develop applications using it. If you read them in the order listed, then you’ll gain understanding more quickly as you read increasingly detailed documents. Note that a lot of the documentation is available both online and in the SDK_ROOT/docs/index.html directory on your machine. If you have a fast enough connection, I would suggest using the on-line versions since they will be more up to date.

Here’s the order in which I suggest you read the documentation:

• What is Android? Explains what Android is and gives a high-level overview of its features and architecture. Don’t dive into the links just yet — just get a feel for this overall document.
• Read the Anatomy of an Android Application page. This details the four building blocks of an Android app: Activity, Intent Receiver, Service and Content Provider. Again, don’t follow the links just yet — just get an overview of the architecture. You may want to reread sections on Activities and Intent Receivers — gaining an understanding of these concepts is critical to understanding how to build an Android application. If you don’t get it yet, you’ll see it again when you go through the Notepad Application Tutorial.
• Next read the Development Tools document. Again — just get a flavor, don’t dive into the detail yet.
• Read the Lifecycle of an Android Application page.
• Now, finally, it’s time to get your hands dirty. Work through the Hello Android page. Make sure you actually do it using Eclipse.

• Now go back and read the rest of the Installing the SDK document — the bottom half of it details some great debugging tips and features.
• Next, go through the Notepad Application Tutorial. This is where the rubber really meets the road. If you spend the time to go through this series of exercises and really understand the code, you will be well on your way to becoming an Android expert.
• Read the Developing Android Applications pages. This will take some time — these articles go into a lot of detail about several topics including how to implement the UI, data storage/retrieval and the security model.
• Finally, go back through this list and follow the links in the previous documents as topics interest you.

There’s a lot of documentation, but if flows together nicely, reflecting the architecture of the environment.

Dissecting the SDK

Whenever I download an SDK, I like to take a look at the files I’ve installed. Often, there is a wealth of information hidden in the SDK itself that is not readily visible from the documentation. So here’s what you’ll find in the Android SDK on a Windows machine:

• android.jar - The Android application framework. Unzipping this jar reveals the entire class structure and all of the supporting classes of the framework. Currently there is no source.
• docs - 100 megabytes worth of documentation, samples, etc.
• samples - Six different sample applications - ApiDemos, HelloActivity, LunarLander, NotePad, SkeletonApp and Snake
• tools - the various SDK binaries such as aapt, acp, and emulator live here.
  • lib - various templates and supporting jar files live in this directory
    • activityCreator - the activityCreator python application lives here.
    • images - The Linux file system images are found in this directory: ramdis.img, system.img and userdata.img. They are YAFFS2 file system images, so I couldn’t open them without additional kernel support on my Fedora system.
      • skins - supporting emulator graphics for HVGA and QVGA screens in both landscape and portrait format.

Exercising the SDK

Now that you have read the documentation and set up and debugged a simple project, it’s time to look at some real code. Since Google has provided us with several sample applications, the best place to begin is by examining them.

1. If you have not already done so, execute the first few sections of Google’s install document. Stop after you’ve installed the Eclipse plugin successfully.
2. Now work through the Hello Android page if you haven’t already. This will get you started working with Android applications and the debugger. Note that it’s probably a good idea to create a new workspace for your Android projects if you already use Eclipse.
3. Next we’re going to set up Eclipse projects for each of the sample applications. You can never have too much sample code. I’ll walk through setting up the Lunar Lander example and leave it as an exercise to the reader to set up the rest.
   1. Bring up the same Eclipse workspace that you used for the Hello Android, and close the project (Right click on the project in package explorer->Close Project).
   2. File->New->Android Project
   3. Project Name: LunarLander
   4. Click the “Create Project from existing source” radio button
   5. Browse to the samples/LunarLander directory in the SDK. If you find the right directory, the Properties fields will auto-fill with the correct information from the Package.
   6. Click Finish
   7. Bring up Eclipse’s Console window (Window->Show View->Console) if it’s not already visible in a tab at the bottom of the screen. It will show you the build process that Eclipse went through to create the application.
   8. Create a Run Configuration: Run->Open Run Dialog
   9. Highlight “Android Application” in the treeview to the left.
   10. Click the “New button”.
   11. Name: Lunar Lander
   12. Click the Browse button next to Project
   13. Double-click the LunarLander project and hit OK
   14. Click the down arrow for the Activity and choose the one and only Activity: com.google.android.lunarlander.LunarLander
   15. Click Apply
   16. Click Run
   17. Switch to the Emulator and play a few rounds of Lunar Lander. Kinda fun.

Repeat for the other applications in the samples directory. This exercise should only take a few minutes — besides, the Snake game is fun too! If you’ve taken the time to go through the Notepad Application Tutorial, then you’ll be familiar with the NotePad sample — however, the NotePad sample is fully developed and has features beyond the NotePad developed during the Tutorial.

A File System Explorer Application

Finally, we’ll use our new understanding of the Android to develop a simple file system explorer. The version in this article is pretty simple, but it can serve as a jumping-off point for a more serious application down the road.

Design

Before we start writing code, let’s think about what a reasonable file system browser should do. It should

• Phase I features
  • Show a list of files and directories
  • Allow the user to navigate through the directory structure by clicking on directories
  • Warn the user that he has clicked on a file
• Phase II features
  • Allow the user to display a dump of a file when it is clicked
  • Use a tree view instead of a simple list
  • Show a dialog box with the filesystem information (size, permissions, etc) when the user clicks on an icon next to each file
  • Give this application permissions to read any file on the file system
• Phase III features
  • Do all of phase II with pretty graphics, such as thumbnails, instead of boring dropdowns and list boxes
  • Execute applications that we understand, such as mp3 files

Process

This article will only cover Phase I of the project — but when we’re done, we’ll have a functional file system explorer in just a few dozen lines of code.

New Android Project
(Click to enlarge)
It works!

If you clicked above to follow the hands-on example, you found that in about twenty lines of Java, and a small amount of XML, you’ve created a useful little application that will allow you to explore the Android’s file system. For example, I found the ringtones in /system/media/audio/ringtones, as shown below.

Oooh, ringtones
(Click to enlarge)

As I mentioned in the design section, a lot can be done with this application, and we’ve hardly touched the surface of what you can do with the Android application environment. There’s three billion cell phones out there. I suspect Google will get their fair share of them, so start cranking out code!

Conclusion

Android is a well-engineered development environment. Writing an Eclipse plug-in was a smart move by Google — one that should be emulated by other SDK developers. Eclipse gives a developer and environment where he can really think about the business problem without worrying about the boring details. Adding the functionality of the plugin helps developers just sit down and start coding — without having to worry about all the ins and outs of configuration files and the like.

Dislikes

Android is brand new to the general developer’s world. As I write this, it’s Wednesday, and the SDK came out on Monday of this week. Since it’s brand new, there are some little problems that will have to be solved in the coming releases.

• Many more examples for the APIs.
• A more thorough explanation of what does and does not work under the emulator. My first example application was a simple MP3 player.
• Release the source code. This will make it a lot easier to debug Android applications, as well as write them in the style that the Google developers wrote them.

Likes

Theres a lot to like about Android:

• It’s by Google — so it has a company with some clout behind it.
• Application Developers write their code in Java. Since the learning curve for Java is much less than that of C/C++/ObjectiveC, there will be many many developers who are eager to start writing applications for Android.
• The SDK and API are well designed. There is some complexity there, and as I mentioned, the Documentation needs improvement — but a well designed system is easier to understand and learn, even without lots of great examples.

High Tech Computer (HTC) is developing a mobile phone that will use the open-source Android software created by Google for its operating system. The phone will be called Dream and have a large touchscreen LucidTouch-Profile Feb-08 and full QWERTY keypad. The handset is over 5 inches long and 3 inches wide and has a keypad that swivels out from underneath the screen.htc.gif

HTC is not the only company that is developing a mobile phone around the Android operating system. Samsung has joined the hunt to create a device that utilizes Android.

HTC was the first company to announce it was building a phone around Android. Other members of the Open Handset Alliance, a group dedicated to promoting Android, are also believed to be developing handsets designed around the operating system. Over 30 companies have joined the Open handset Alliance. Samsung and Motorola are two manufactures who belong to the alliance and may be developing Android phones of their own.

The Android Developer Challenge is proceeding nicely. We’re excited about the interest people have shown so far and have enjoyed talking to everyone working on new Android Apps.

As a quick reminder, the first phase of the challenge will be ending on April 14. In the Android Developer Challenge I, the 50 most promising entries received by April 14 will each receive a $25,000 award to fund further development. Those selected will then be eligible for even greater recognition via ten $275,000 awards and ten $100,000 awards.

Keep working on your applications, and be sure to post in the forums if you have any questions!

David McLaughlin
Android Advocate